CHALLENGES INVOLVED IN DEPLOYING BACTERIOPHAGES FOR
CONTROL OF BACTERIAL PLANT DISEASES. J. B. Jones (1), F.
Iriarte (2), B. Balogh (3), A. Obradovic (4), and M. T. Momol (1)
(1) Department of Plant Pathology, University of Florida, Gainesville, FL USA;
(2) Department of Plant Pathology, Iowa State University, Ames, IA USA;
(3) Department of Plant Pathology & Ecology,The Connecticut Agricultural
Experiment Station, New Haven, CT USA; and (4) Plant Pathology Department,
Faculty of Agriculture, University of Belgrade, Belgrade-Zemun, Serbia.
Abstract: Biological control using bacteriophages has proven to be an excellent
alternative to conventional chemical control strategies for controlling bacterial
spot of tomato. In several studies which we conducted, bacteriophages
outperformed standard chemical control practices (principally copper-based
compounds) and other biological control strategies. One of the major
challenges in deploying bacteriophages relates to the ability of phages to
persist at levels necessary for being effective in limiting bacterial populations.
Persistence of phages in the phyllosphere is influenced by various factors
including the presence or absence of the phage host, sunlight irradiation
(especially in the UV zone), temperature, desiccation, and copper-based
bactericides. These factors were evaluated in two studies (Balogh 2007,
Ph.D. dissertation, University of Florida; Iriarte et al., 2007, Appl. & Env.
Microbiol. 73:1704-1711) for persistence of non-formulated phage (nothing
added to enhance longevity) and formulated phage (phage mixed with skim
milk). Field studies were conducted to address the effects of a copper
bactericide and sunlight on phage survival. Copper was shown to adversely
affect phage if applied the same day as phage applications but not if applied
at least 4 days prior to phage application. Sunlight UV was evaluated for
detrimental effects on formulated and non-formulated phage survival on
tomato foliage in which phage was applied at four time points during the day
(early morning, midmorning, early afternoon, and late evening). In that study
in which UV (UVA and UVB) irradiation and phage populations were
monitored, populations declined most precipitously in the early afternoon
when intensity of UV irradiation was highest. Application of phage in the
evening resulted in minimal reduction in phage populations on leaf surfaces
when assayed the following morning. There was clearly a negative
correlation between UV intensity and phage populations with the protective
formulation consistently reducing the deleterious effects of UV. In growth
room experiments, ambient temperature was shown to have a pronounced
effect on non-formulated phage but not on formulated phages. We also
49
determined the effects of desiccation and fluorescent light on phage survival.
Desiccation without exposure to light caused a slight decline in phage
populations after 60 days, whereas desiccation combined with fluorescent
light was much more destructive. The formulation protected phage from
adverse effects of both factors. Phage persistence was most dramatically
affected by UV, while the other factors had much less pronounced effects.
The skim milk formulated phage reduced deleterious effects of the studied
environmental factors. Combining the use of formulated phage with evening
applications potentially should optimize efficacy. Future research should
focus on developing other strategies to optimize stability of phages on the
leaf surface.